Showing posts with label RTI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label RTI. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

NAC's style of drafting Bills

The National Advisory Council (NAC) has in its agenda, among other things, giving legislative inputs to the Government. This it does, by preparing draft Bills on important issues. But little is known about how it goes about this exercise, notwithstanding the transparency which marks its website. The Draft Bill on Prevention of Communal and Targeted violence, prepared by NAC, is being submitted to the Government for its consideration, after NAC put its first version on its website, inviting comments. After the deadline for receiving the comments was over on June 4, the NAC agreed to 49 amendments on its first draft. Even though the NAC had constituted a Drafting Committee and an Advisory Committee, very little is known about what were the comments of members in these committees, and whether the NAC considered them at all at the drafting stage, and if some of them were rejected, why. In this article, I bring to light some of the misgivings on the final draft which the NAC has produced. If some of the critics who served on the AC and DC are to be believed, the NAC's in-house style of democratic decision making leaves a lot to be desired. If consultation with experts proves to be a farce, NAC's credibility will be at stake.

In another article, I examine the AG's advisory opinion to exclude CBI from the RTI Act's purview, and question some of his assumptions. The Law Ministry, which favoured a partial exemption of CBI from the Act, is no less culpable. The erstwhile Law Minister, Veerappa Moily, might have been shifted to another Ministry for other reasons, but one wishes the Prime Minister considered this as reason enough for shifting him.

Thursday, June 30, 2011

CBI’s exemption from RTI Act: Is the AG’s opinion justified?

By Arushi Garg

The government’s notification exempting the CBI under Section 24 of the RTI Act (which allows exemption of intelligence gathering agencies from the RTI Act) has sparked a controversy. A PIL has been filed in the Madras HC challenging its constitutional validity. In the light of the above, the Attorney General’s opinion on the same becomes pertinent, since the exemption has been granted solely based on his opinion. This exemption is in contradiction of the reports of both the Law Ministry as well as the Department of Personnel and Training.

The primary argument in the AG’s opinion, a copy of which is with the LAOT, is that the CBI’s investigation affects the security of the nation and the term “intelligence” extended not just to information gathered for the prevention of the occurence of events, but also post-event intelligence gathering. The AG has used the term `intelligence’ primarily to refer to information relating to the security or defence of a nation.

Since many cases investigated by the CBI are related to the security of India, he concluded that CBI was eligible for an exemption. Even if it is assumed that intelligence gathering need not always be preventive, and covers investigation, his opinion fails to take into account the fact that no investigation would be hindered by covering the CBI under the RTI since information relating to pending investigations has already been exempted under Section 8(1)(h) (as I have argued on June 16 on the Legal Notes page).

There could be no interference with the process of investigation, or with the security of India, even if the information is related to substantive aspects of the investigation, let alone the other procedural aspects (such as administration, personnel, accounts/finance budget and training) for which no exception is carved out in the AG’s opinion. The CBI investigation would already be complete at the time any RTI application is filed.

The least convincing part of the AG’s opinion is his refusal to recommend notification of only those parts under Section 24 as are related to intelligence gathering. He justifies it because Section 24 exempts not just intelligence agencies but also organisations dealing with the security of the country. This seems to imply that even if the investigation of the CBI doesn’t concern intelligence gathering, it will still magically be connected to the security of India. This argument crumbles in the face of numerous Supreme Court rulings that have iterated over and over again that the scope of matters dealing with security is extremely narrow, and not all breaches of public order and law and order are concerns related to security.

Case law on the subject, as cited by the AG, can be traced to the judgment of Hidayatullah, J., in the Ram Manohar Lohia case, wherein it was stated:

“One has to imagine three concentric circles. Law and order represents the largest circle within which is the next circle representing public order and the smallest circle represents security of State. It is then easy to see that an act may affect law and order but not public order just as an act may affect public order but not security of the State.”

It was also observed that “When two drunkards quarrel and fight there is disorder but not public disorder. They can be dealt with under the powers to maintain law and order but cannot be detained on the ground that they were disturbing public order. Suppose that the two fighters were of rival communities and one of them tried to raise communal passions. The problem is still one of law and order but it raises the apprehension of public disorder.”

The import of this statement (which later developed into the “Even Tempo” test, as it has been referred to by the AG) is that if the disruption of law and order involves only certain individuals, and not the society at large, only then can it be regarded as a disturbance of public order. The scope for what is to be regarded as a threat to security is then even smaller, and cases involving individuals cannot be included within this narrow scope.

This observation has been quoted with approval till very recently by High Courts as well as the Supreme Court. In fact, just last year, a division bench of the Supreme Court reaffirmed this understanding. Thus, while public order is a broad area, only the “most serious and aggravated forms of public disorder” endanger public security.

This distinction has been acknowledged and in fact, explored in rather comprehensive detail by the AG. But his opinion then goes on to enumerate the cases investigated by the CBI which have a bearing on national security while not dealing with the fact that a substantial number of them don’t. Many of these cases involve allegations of specific crimes committed against specific people that do not meet the threshold for cases involving national security.

The most famous example that comes to mind is the Aarushi Talwar case that was handled by the CBI. The CBI has also dealt with the charges of kidnapping and attempted rape against Noida based businessman Moninder Singh Pandher. Both are instances of brutal and shocking crimes, but had no ramifications on the “security” of the State as has been understood by the courts of this country. Curiously, AG's opinion expressly states that a separation of the various types of cases investigated by the CBI is not possible because “we are concerned not just with intelligence but also with the security of the State.”

The fact that the provisos to Section 24 anyway forbid exemption of information relating to corruption and violation of human rights has also been wilfully overlooked by the blanket exception that has been carved out for the CBI. Even commentators who have defended the inclusion of the CBI have advocated laying down rules that limits this exemption in accordance with the Section 24 provisos, and providing the exemption only during the pendency of the investigation.

Based on the above, despite the AG’s faith in this exception, it is unlikely that it is justified in law.

(The author who has just completed an internship with LAOT, is a IV Year student of the NALSAR University of Law, Hyderabad)

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

SC vs. CIC: Does SC have a case?

The Supreme Court has gone to the High Court again, appealing against a CIC order. If it was about the declaration of assets earlier, this time it is to assert the primacy of the Supreme Court Rules over the RTI Act.



The main issue at hand is whether the non-obstante clause in Section 22 of the RTI Act, 2005, overrides the Supreme Court Rules. According to the statutory provision in question, the provisions of the RTI Act are to have effect “notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in the Official Secrets Act, 1923, and any other law for the time being in force or in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law other than this Act.”



Order XII, Rule 2 states that the Supreme Court may provide all documents, records and pleadings associated with a case to anyone who was not a party to the case if good cause is shown for seeking this information and prescribed procedure (including payment of prescribed fees) is duly followed.



Both provisions have been put in place to facilitate transparency and in that sense, are not inherently inconsistent with each other. But there are some crucial differences. Unlike the Supreme Court Rules, the RTI Act provides for a time limit within which such information is sought, offers no discretion if the information in question is covered by the Act and does not require the party to state any reason at all for seeking this information. A system of differential pricing is followed with respect to the payment of fees under the RTI Act.



The CIC has held that since both provisions are two ways of achieving the same end, there is no inconsistency of the sort covered by Section 22 and it is therefore open to the parties to seek information through whatever channel they use. Such an inconsistency does emerge when information is to be mandatorily made available to an applicant under the RTI Act, but is denied to him or her under the Supreme Court Rules. In such a situation, the RTI Act trumps the Supreme Court Rules since Section 22 is then operationalized. Any other interpretation would be a violation of the right to information that has been recognized as a fundamental right by the Supreme Court.



In coming to this conclusion, the CIC discussed two important maxims. The first of these is - lex posterior derogat priori - non est novum ut priores

lages ad posteriores trahantur
- which means that an earlier Act must give way to a later one, if the two cannot be reconciled. The CIC held that this was to be done in only those rare situations where no harmonious construction of the two was possible. Thus, both provisions were recognized as valid modes of obtaining information unless there was an obvious conflict of the sort described above.



The other maxim discussed generalia specialibus non derogant(i.e., general things do not derogate from special things) was similarly dealt with. The CIC held that the general provisions of the RTI Act would not take away from the SC Rules unless there was a stark inconsistency between the two that led to an inability to apply this maxim.



The SC has approached the High Court challenging such a construction.

Apart from the grounds that have already been dealt with by the CIC, a fresh ground of appeal seems to be that the SC Rules are framed under the direct authority of the Constitution and should therefore trump the RTI Act This argument must necessarily fail. The SC Rules have been framed under the authority of Article 145 of the Constitution and are “[s]ubject to the provisions of any law made by Parliament.” The interpretation given by the CIC seems to be sound in law and is unlikely to be overturned.



However, the related issue of the kind of information sought, rather than the mode of information might be well worth exploring. The information sought by the applicant extended to “reasons for judicial decisions.” Arguably, the requirement that all decisions must be reasoned decisions has already found its way into the corpus of principles of natural justice, and there is little to be gained by allowing applications demanding reasons beyond those that have already been furnished. In that sense, these applications would largely be superfluous, and would unnecessarily consume time and resources.



ADDENDUM



Moreover, Section 4(1)(d) of the RTI Act, explicitly mentions that the ambit of the Act extends to reasons for all administrative and quasi-judicial decisions. Had the Legislature wanted to include judicial decisions, nothing would have been easier than to mention that in the said provision. The Legislative intent was clearly to exclude judicial decisions from the ambit of the RTI Act.



[Contributed by Arushi Garg]

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Article Alerts

Here are links to some of my recent articles which may be of interest to readers:

1. On the demand for JPC probe into the 2G scam.

2.Uncles on Bench

3.On the proposed amendment to RTI Act.

4. On the Supreme Court's hearing on CVC

5.On the case against Arundhati Roy and Teesta and Arundhati Roy's speech. Incidentally, I felt after reading Ananya Vajpayee's article in Seminar, both are similar in substance, if not in tone and tenor.(The Problem, Nov.2010 issue)

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Frontline on Ayodhya judgment



Frontline's latest cover story is a comprehensive analysis of the Lucknow Bench's judgment. Among the articles are those written by A.G.Noorani and me here and here. Interviews with Zafaryab Jilani, Ravishankar Prasad, Rajeev Dhavan, and Justice Rajindar Sachar are other highlights.

Readers may also be interested in reading my article on the latest CIC decision on the proactive disclosure of draft laws by Governments, and my article reviewing six books on implementation of environment law.

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Dissecting the Right to Information Act

Frontline's recent issue is a celebration of the strengths of the Right to Information Act, and a critique of its flaws, as the activists see it. There are 10 components to the cover story, of which I have written three. Though the readers may find all the contributions informative, I'm linking my articles, for the purpose of record, and of course, to invite feedback.

1. Analysis of proposed amendments to RTI Act

2. Appointment of information Commissioners & the need for reform

3. Secrecy around bill on whistle-blowers

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Article alerts

* My analysis of MCOCA and its application to Hindutva terror groups.

* My appreciation of the Supreme Court's judgment in the James Laine case.

*How lack of transparency in the appointment of information commissioners is likely to weaken the RTI Act.

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Frontline's cover on Bhopal verdict

Frontline has covered the verdict convicting & sentencing the 8 accused in the 1984 Bhopal disaster case comprehensively. Apart from my articles and interview with Himanshu Rajan Sharma, readers may be interested in the rare article by Upendra Baxi, who calls it Fourth Catastrophe. The entire cover story can be downloaded and read here.

Readers may also be interested in reading my article (pages 34-36)on the Central Information Commission's decision to appeal against a Delhi High Court's judgment questioning its powers, and my review of Prof.M.P.Jain's Indian Constitutional Law (6th revised edition)and Mithi Mukherjee's India in the Shadows of Empire.